A. John Kennedy and Others v. State of Tamil Nadu and Others (with connected Contempt Petition)
Background
Following an earlier eviction and restoration order for encroachments in a Tamil Nadu tiger reserve landscape, disputes arose over commercial silk cotton cultivation inside Reserved Forest land, land titles granted within the forest, and whether thousands of occupants could claim protection as forest dwellers before eviction.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court held that silk cotton cultivation, a deliberately planted commercial crop since the 1930s, cannot be treated as protected minor forest produce, since commercial cultivation changes the forest's very character. Of three categories of occupants, only those permanently residing in and depending on the forest could even be considered for forest-rights protection: those with only temporary residence or living outside the forest boundary are automatically excluded. The Court set strict deadlines for the claims verification process and constituted a Special Committee headed by a former Chief Justice of India to scrutinise claims decisions.
Lesson Learnt
Occupying or cultivating land inside a notified Reserved Forest, even for decades, does not by itself create a legal right to stay: forest-rights protection requires actual residence and dependence on the forest, verified through the Act's own process.