Abhishek Sharma vs. The State NCT of Delhi
Background
The appellant and a minor co-accused were convicted of murdering a man who confronted them over consuming intoxicants, and of burning their clothes afterward. CCTV showed both fleeing, but only the minor was seen holding the knife, recovered from his possession alone.
Decision Breakdown
The Court found no evidence the appellant delivered the fatal wound or held any weapon. Since he fled alongside the knife-wielding co-accused, he shared common intention to cause grievous hurt, not death. His murder conviction was downgraded to voluntarily causing grievous hurt with a dangerous weapon, and since he'd already served more time than the reduced sentence required, he was ordered released immediately.
Lesson Learnt
Being present with, and fleeing alongside, someone who commits a more serious crime does not automatically make a companion equally guilty of murder: courts look at what each person actually did or intended.