Akshay Aditya vs. The State of NCT of Delhi & Anr.
Background
The complainant alleged the petitioner, a post-graduate medical student, contacted her on Instagram, promised to marry her, and over several months forcibly had sexual intercourse with her on multiple occasions, using threats of self-harm to keep her silent. An FIR was registered under provisions covering both rape and sex induced by a false promise of marriage. The petitioner, already denied anticipatory bail by a trial court, sought it from the High Court, while the State separately asked for his existing interim protection to be cancelled.
Decision Breakdown
The Court held anticipatory bail is an "extraordinary remedy," and that cooperating with investigation doesn't by itself entitle an accused to it. The allegations were of forcible intercourse on specific dates, falling under the more serious rape provision. The Court was troubled that the petitioner's phone, which he claimed held exonerating evidence, "went missing" within hours of him mentioning it, and that he had deleted chats. The application was dismissed and existing interim protection withdrawn, though he may still seek regular bail after surrender.
Lesson Learnt
Courts will not grant anticipatory bail just because an accused has cooperated with police; where the core allegation is forced sex and the accused's account of "lost" evidence looks suspicious, custodial interrogation can be ordered.