Aman Kashyap vs. State of NCT of Delhi and connected matters
Background
During the February 2020 communal riots in North-East Delhi, a 22-year-old man was chased and beaten by a mob near Brijpuri T-Point and died of his injuries. Five men, the appellants, were identified by a civilian witness and three police witnesses (including a beat constable who already knew them) as having been at the front of the mob. The trial court convicted all five of rioting and culpable homicide not amounting to murder, sentencing each to seven years.
Decision Breakdown
The appellants challenged the identification evidence as unreliable: a partial witness retraction, statements recorded over a month later, no formal identification parade. The High Court held these weaknesses didn't amount to reasonable doubt: the beat constable's identification carried independent weight since he knew the accused from his regular duties, and the delay was explained by the chaos of the riots. On the legal question of individual guilt within a mob, the Court applied Section 149 IPC's "unlawful assembly" doctrine: a member of a mob sharing a common violent purpose can be held responsible for the group's actions without proof of his own individual blow. All five appeals were dismissed.
Lesson Learnt
If identified as part of a violent mob, Indian law allows conviction for the group's crime even without proof of personally striking the fatal blow, so long as willing membership in a mob with shared violent purpose is proven: being present with others of similar intent is itself legally dangerous.