Antonetto J D'Souza v. Aldila Braganza and Others

Criminal Appeal · 2026 INSC 1032Decided 22 Sept 2026
Criminal Appeal No. 4092 of 2026
Justice Ujjal Bhuyan · Justice Atul S. Chandurkar

Background

The appellant alleged that his neighbour (the accused) and her late father-in-law had built a structure in Goa using a forged, interpolated copy of an approved building plan, and lodged a police complaint in 2012. After investigation, a chargesheet for forgery and cheating was filed, and in 2017 a Magistrate framed charges, finding enough prima facie material despite the original (allegedly forged) plan never being recovered. The accused's revision against that order failed, and a first writ petition challenging the FIR and chargesheet was also dismissed by the High Court in 2023. Undeterred, the accused filed a second writ petition in 2024 raising the same core argument, absence of the original plan, and this time a Single Judge of the High Court accepted it and discharged her.

Decision Breakdown

The Supreme Court set aside the discharge order and restored the criminal case. It held that the accused could not repeatedly re-litigate the very same "absence of original plan" argument that a Division Bench had already rejected in 2023. That earlier, unchallenged order was binding, and the principle of "issue estoppel" barred reagitating it. On the merits too, the Court held that the absence of the original allegedly-forged document does not automatically defeat a forgery prosecution; whether forgery is proved is a matter for trial based on the totality of evidence (including witness testimony and forensic material), not something to be decided by simply demanding production of a physical document at the charge-framing stage. The Court also noted that at the charge-framing stage, courts must only see if there is a prima facie/grave suspicion against the accused, not sift and weigh evidence as if conducting a mini-trial. The trial was ordered to proceed and be expedited given its long pendency since 2012.

Lesson Learnt

Once a High Court has rejected a particular legal argument in one round of proceedings and that order is not further challenged, the same argument cannot be recycled in a fresh petition; also, in forgery cases, the missing original document is not by itself a ground for discharge. The prosecution can still prove its case through other evidence at trial.

Criminal LawSupreme Court of India

Sau. Kamalbai Waman Patil v. The State of Maharashtra

The Supreme Court restored the acquittal. Since all four were charged jointly on a "common intention" theory with no separate standalone charge against the mother-in-law alone, convicting just her for the same joint offence after the others were acquitted effectively invented a new, unframed accusation. The High Court had also wrongly relied on a single uncorroborated dying declaration while ignoring that a key eyewitness was never examined, and wrongly held the accused's silence against her before the prosecution had even made out a prima facie case.

Decided 5 Nov 2026Read case
Criminal LawSupreme Court of India

Sri Sujit Das and Ors. Etc. v. Union of India

The Supreme Court held that the Article 22(2) 24-hour clock starts from the moment a person's liberty is actually curtailed, not from whatever later time an agency chooses to record as the "formal arrest." Since production before the Magistrate came nearly 27 hours after actual interception, this breached the mandatory constitutional limit, compounded by an unexplained 18-hour gap violating the companion "reasonable time" safeguard. The Court laid down detailed guidelines for how this clock must be computed and held three High Court rulings didn't state the correct law, treating the constitutional violation as an independent ground for release that bypassed the NDPS Act's strict bail bar entirely.

Decided 5 Nov 2026Read case
Criminal LawSupreme Court of India

N. Sridhar Reddy v. The State of A.P. through Secretary and Others (with connected appeals)

The Supreme Court held a foreign divorce decree isn't automatically binding in India: it must be tested against the matrimonial law actually governing the parties. Since the couple married under Hindu law, and "irretrievable breakdown" isn't a recognized ground under the Hindu Marriage Act, the UK decree couldn't be recognized in India, so the first marriage remained subsisting and the bigamy charge stood regardless of his acquired British citizenship. Bigamy being a continuing offence, delay in complaint wasn't a defence. However, the Court quashed proceedings against the parents and second wife, since mere awareness or relationship-based inference isn't enough for criminal liability: conspiracy requires proof of an actual overt act.

Decided 3 Nov 2026Read case
Criminal LawSupreme Court of India

Shekappa And Ors. v. State of Karnataka

The Supreme Court upheld the convictions, finding the trial court's acquittal "wholly unreasonable, perverse and not based on the record." The eyewitness testimony of the two widows was natural, trustworthy, and corroborated by medical evidence and proof of motive: being related to the deceased doesn't automatically make a witness unreliable. The Court rejected the trial court's reliance on the absence of eyewitness names in the inquest report (legally irrelevant, since inquests serve only to establish cause of death), a minor FIR delay (adequately explained), and a doctor's speculative digestion-based time-of-death estimate (too inconclusive to override direct eyewitness evidence).

Decided 3 Nov 2026Read case
Criminal LawSupreme Court of India

Goverdhan v. State of Rajasthan

The Supreme Court acquitted the husband. The letters' authorship rested solely on an untested handwriting expert's report: the expert was never examined in court, and settled law holds such uncorroborated opinion cannot sustain a conviction. Even treating the letters as genuine, their mixed content (abuse alongside pleas for reconciliation) didn't amount to "instigation," and there was no proximate causal link between the letters and the suicide, notably, no Section 498-A charge was ever framed despite the alleged ongoing harassment.

Decided 3 Nov 2026Read case
Criminal LawSupreme Court of India

A. Arun v. Varsha Sharma & Ors.

The officer appeared in person and tendered an unconditional written apology, admitting error and regretting not owning up to the mistake sooner. The Court accepted the apology and ordered the adverse remarks expunged, while stressing that preventive detention powers directly affect personal liberty and must be exercised with "utmost circumspection," and clarifying that an apology doesn't excuse future lapses. The underlying finding that the detention itself was invalid was left undisturbed.

Decided 2 Nov 2026Read case
Antonetto J D'Souza v. Aldila Braganza and Others