Dr. I.A. Khan vs. State & Anr.
Background
Dr. Khan had a property-development dispute allegedly settled in 2016 via three post-dated cheques totalling Rs. 30 lakh. Two bounced for insufficient funds; the third was returned over an alleged alteration. The trial court convicted him, sentencing 10 months and ordering Rs. 42 lakh compensation; an appellate court upheld this. He argued the cheques were only security, not real payment, and one was fraudulently altered.
Decision Breakdown
The High Court held that once a person admits signing and handing over a cheque, the law presumes it was for a genuine debt unless the accused shows real evidence otherwise: Khan's unsupported "security" claim didn't meet that bar. It rejected the alteration argument too, finding the amount in words and figures matched. The conviction and compensation were upheld, but the prison sentence was reduced from 10 to 6 months given partial repayments (Rs. 21 lakh) during the case.
Lesson Learnt
Signing and handing over a cheque creates a strong legal presumption that money is owed: prompt, partial repayment during litigation can help reduce a sentence even if it doesn't erase the underlying liability.