Goverdhan v. State of Rajasthan
Background
A wife left her matrimonial home in 2009 alleging dowry harassment and filed a complaint seeking maintenance. Roughly two years later, she died by setting herself on fire at her parents' home. Her mother filed a complaint alleging four threatening letters from the husband had driven her to suicide, leading to a conviction under Section 306 IPC by both the trial court and the Rajasthan High Court, with a 10-year sentence.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court acquitted the husband. The letters' authorship rested solely on an untested handwriting expert's report: the expert was never examined in court, and settled law holds such uncorroborated opinion cannot sustain a conviction. Even treating the letters as genuine, their mixed content (abuse alongside pleas for reconciliation) didn't amount to "instigation," and there was no proximate causal link between the letters and the suicide, notably, no Section 498-A charge was ever framed despite the alleged ongoing harassment.
Lesson Learnt
A serious criminal conviction cannot rest on an untested handwriting expert's opinion alone; abusive words alone don't establish "abetment" of suicide without a proximate, direct causal link to the act, viewed in full context.