Greenlam Industries Limited vs. State of NCT of Delhi
Background
A man named Amit Chopra filed a police case (FIR) alleging an investment fraud of about Rs. 2.14 crore, and transactions flagged on the National Cybercrime Reporting Portal were put on hold in several bank accounts. One flagged payment of Rs. 19,57,212 had gone into Greenlam Industries' HDFC Bank account. In October 2025 a Magistrate ordered the money released to the complainant, even though the police report said the transactions were not yet verified, and without hearing Greenlam. Greenlam said the money was a genuine business payment from another company, Bisnu Chem, but the Magistrate later refused to restore it, saying that would amount to reviewing a judicial order.
Decision Breakdown
The Court found that bank records and the police status report showed the money came from Bisnu Chem, not from the complainant. AU Small Finance Bank admitted the payment had been wrongly tagged to the complaint because of a technical error, and the two transaction reference numbers differed only in their last digits. The release order was unsustainable because it relied on unverified transactions and Greenlam was not given a hearing. Applying the principle of restitution (putting a party back in the position it would have been in had the wrong order not been made), the Court set aside both Magistrate orders to that extent and directed the complainant to return Rs. 19,57,212 within six weeks. His undertaking concerning a property interest stays in place until he repays, and the Court said it had not decided any liability of the banks or the police.
Lesson Learnt
Money in a bank account cannot fairly be handed over to a fraud complainant on unverified portal data without first hearing the account holder. If funds are wrongly transferred under a court order, the court can order them returned rather than forcing the account holder to file a separate suit.