Har Parsad Gaur v. State (NCT of Delhi)
Background
Har Parsad Gaur, a Tehsildar in Delhi, was handling recovery of Rs. 41,425 in unpaid wages that a Labour Court had awarded to a worker, Puran Chand. Puran Chand complained to the Anti-Corruption Bureau that Gaur had demanded a bribe of Rs. 1,000 to forward the recovery cheques, and on 06.01.2003 a trap was laid outside the SBI branch at Tis Hazari, where two chemically treated Rs. 500 notes were recovered from Gaur's coat pocket and his hand wash turned pink. Both the complainant and the independent "shadow" witness died before they could testify, but the trial court convicted Gaur in 2008 and the Delhi High Court upheld the conviction in 2014 (reducing the sentence to one year).
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and acquitted Gaur. It held, following the Constitution Bench in Neeraj Dutta, that the legal presumption of bribery under Section 20 of the PC Act arises only after the prosecution first proves both the demand and the voluntary acceptance of a bribe, and mere recovery of marked notes is not enough. The trap officer had not himself seen or heard any demand; what he said the shadow witness told him was hearsay (second-hand evidence) and inadmissible. Official records also showed that Gaur's office had already sent both cheques to the Labour Department on 28.12.2002, so no work was pending with him on the day of the alleged bribe, making plausible his explanation that the complainant tried to push the money into his pocket while thanking him.
Lesson Learnt
To convict someone of taking a bribe, the prosecution must prove that the official actually demanded and knowingly accepted it; finding marked money on the person is not, by itself, enough. Courts also check official records: if the work was already done, the claim that a bribe was demanded for it becomes doubtful.