Harvinder Singh @ Vimpy Chaddha vs. The State of NCT of Delhi & Anr. and connected matters

Criminal Appeal · CNR No. DLHC010266822022Decided 17 Nov 2026New Delhi Bench
CRL.A. 321/2022, CRL.A. 362/2022, CRL.A. 651/2022CNR: DLHC010266822022
Justice Navin Chawla · Justice Ravinder Dudeja

Background

On the night of 24 September 2011, near the Railway Hospital in central Delhi, a man in police uniform shot Amarjeet Singh Chadha three times inside his car and snatched his gold chains. Patrolling police officers chased the attacker, and a passing motorcyclist, Sunny, who had stopped to help them, was shot in the neck and later died. The attacker, Ajay Kumar Tomar, himself a police officer, was caught after jumping off a bridge, with two pistols and the stolen chains in his possession. The trial court convicted him of both murders and of robbery and gave him life imprisonment, but refused the death penalty.

Decision Breakdown

Three appeals were heard together: Tomar's appeal against his conviction, and appeals by the victim's son and by the State asking for the death penalty. The Court upheld the convictions, finding the eyewitness account supported by the medical evidence, ballistic reports matching the bullets to the seized pistols, his fingerprints on the car, and the recovery of the stolen chains, which the victim's son identified. It held that gaps in the police investigation did not undo this combined evidence. On sentence, it treated his abuse of his position as a police officer and the loss of two lives as serious aggravating factors, but applied the Supreme Court's "rarest of rare" test (death is allowed only when life imprisonment is clearly inadequate and reform is ruled out) and found it was not met. All three appeals were dismissed and the life sentences stand.

Lesson Learnt

A conviction can stand despite flaws in the police investigation when independent pieces of evidence all point to the same person. Even for a grave crime by a police officer, the death penalty remains an exception reserved for the rarest cases, and life imprisonment is the normal punishment for murder.

Criminal LawSupreme Court of India

Bheemanagouda @ Bheemajja v. State by Harapanahalli Police

The Supreme Court allowed the appeal and acquitted him of murder, ordering his immediate release (he had spent over 13 years in custody). It held that the motive was mere conjecture, since relatives only had general gossip about an affair and no witness spoke of any suspicion or quarrel. The "last seen" witnesses' statements were recorded about 58 days late without explanation, and the High Court had relied on them without explaining why it disagreed with the trial court. The recovery of ornaments was doubtful: independent witnesses did not support the disclosure statement, one witness was a regular police witness, another said the police had found the jewellery the day after the incident, and no one proved she was wearing those ornaments when last seen. In any case, possessing a dead person's belongings only raises a presumption of theft, not murder, unless theft and murder are shown to be part of the same incident.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Criminal LawDelhi High Court

Court on its Own Motion vs. State

On the first question, the Court held that bail does not by itself legalise a foreign national's continued stay or act as a substitute for a valid visa. The bail court deals only with the past offence; whether the person may stay in future is for the Central Government to decide under Section 3 of the 1946 Act or Section 7 of the 2025 Act, which allow measures such as fixing a place of residence or limiting movement. On the second question, the answer was no: such cases are not to be treated differently from other criminal cases, and a foreign national is protected by Article 21 of the Constitution (the right to life and personal liberty). On the third question, the Court held that a court may grant bail with reasonable conditions such as a fixed residence, limits on movement and regular reporting, but cannot order that the person be kept in a detention centre, because that would defeat the bail itself; only the government can order such detention. The Court also noted that the 2025 Act allows these offences to be compounded (settled by paying a penalty) under Section 25, after which the person may leave India.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Criminal LawDelhi High Court

Chhotey Lal & Jai Dev vs. The State and connected matters

The Court found that the allegations against the father-in-law and brother-in-law were vague and general, with no specific act linked to either of them, and acquitted both, relying on Supreme Court rulings that sweeping claims against all in-laws cannot support a conviction. As for the husband, the evidence did not show cruelty linked to a dowry demand "soon before" her death, so the dowry death conviction under Section 304-B could not stand. But the Court found he had treated her with cruelty under Section 498-A, which covers wilful conduct likely to drive a woman to suicide even without a dowry demand: she had left him over their discord, he took her back after promising before elders to treat her well, and within about six weeks of that promise she took her own life. Following Supreme Court rulings that a court may convict for a proven offence even if no formal charge was framed for it, provided the accused suffers no unfairness, it converted his conviction to abetment of suicide under Section 306 IPC, kept his sentence for cruelty, and sentenced him for abetment to the time he had already spent in jail.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Criminal LawDelhi High Court

Karunesh Singh vs. State of NCT of Delhi

The applicant said he was himself a victim, because two people from a nearby village had misused his wallet after he shared its details with them, and that he had complained to the police. The Court noted that the money reached his wallet in November 2025, yet he complained only in February 2026, and only after the police had sent him a notice to join the investigation. He had also kept making payments from the same wallet in the meantime, so the Court did not believe he was unaware of the money. The same wallet was also linked to another cyber fraud case registered in Srinagar. The Court found the police's need to question him in custody reasonable, to trace the full chain of people who benefited, and dismissed the anticipatory bail application.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Criminal LawDelhi High Court

Amit Rana vs. The State (Govt of NCT of Delhi) and Anr

The Court granted anticipatory bail under Section 482 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023. It noted that the applicant left India before the FIR and before the Look Out Circular was opened, that no notice under Section 35 BNSS had been given to him, that his travel documents matched his account, and that his parents had already joined the investigation. Relying on Supreme Court rulings, it said custodial interrogation is ordinarily not needed where an accused cooperates, and that the police can seek cancellation of bail if he does not. It also weighed that the relationship had existed since November 2025 while the FIR came only in August 2026. Bail was on a Rs. 50,000 bond with strict conditions, including no leaving Delhi or India without permission, no contact with the complainant or witnesses, joining the investigation on 19 November 2026, giving access to his devices, and surrendering his passport.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Criminal LawDelhi High Court

Vikas Gahlot vs. State NCT of Delhi

The Court refused interim bail because of the serious allegations, his multiple pending cases and the history of the surgery date changing. It still accepted that it could not ignore his father's illness. Relying on Rules 1203 and 1209 of the Delhi Prison Rules, 2018, it granted custody parole instead: a supervised visit where the prisoner stays in police custody throughout. He may visit the hospital on 19 and 20 November 2026 and on each day his father stays admitted, up to seven days, from 9 am to 6 pm, escorted by plain-clothes police, without using a mobile phone and without meeting any co-accused. The Court noted that the six-hour limit in the Rules is not absolute, but custody parole cannot become a substitute for bail, and the order would not take effect if the surgery was not verified or was postponed.

Decided 18 Nov 2026Read case
Harvinder Singh @ Vimpy Chaddha vs. The State of NCT of…