Harvinder Singh @ Vimpy Chaddha vs. The State of NCT of Delhi & Anr. and connected matters
Background
On the night of 24 September 2011, near the Railway Hospital in central Delhi, a man in police uniform shot Amarjeet Singh Chadha three times inside his car and snatched his gold chains. Patrolling police officers chased the attacker, and a passing motorcyclist, Sunny, who had stopped to help them, was shot in the neck and later died. The attacker, Ajay Kumar Tomar, himself a police officer, was caught after jumping off a bridge, with two pistols and the stolen chains in his possession. The trial court convicted him of both murders and of robbery and gave him life imprisonment, but refused the death penalty.
Decision Breakdown
Three appeals were heard together: Tomar's appeal against his conviction, and appeals by the victim's son and by the State asking for the death penalty. The Court upheld the convictions, finding the eyewitness account supported by the medical evidence, ballistic reports matching the bullets to the seized pistols, his fingerprints on the car, and the recovery of the stolen chains, which the victim's son identified. It held that gaps in the police investigation did not undo this combined evidence. On sentence, it treated his abuse of his position as a police officer and the loss of two lives as serious aggravating factors, but applied the Supreme Court's "rarest of rare" test (death is allowed only when life imprisonment is clearly inadequate and reform is ruled out) and found it was not met. All three appeals were dismissed and the life sentences stand.
Lesson Learnt
A conviction can stand despite flaws in the police investigation when independent pieces of evidence all point to the same person. Even for a grave crime by a police officer, the death penalty remains an exception reserved for the rarest cases, and life imprisonment is the normal punishment for murder.