Irfan Tariq Antoo vs. State (NCT of Delhi)
Background
The appellant, one of many accused in a large Kashmir terror-conspiracy case, allegedly supplied grenades and helped conceal ammunition. Arrested in December 2021, he'd been in custody roughly five years with only 21 of 356 witnesses examined.
Decision Breakdown
The Court acknowledged such prolonged detention raises genuine Article 21 concerns even under UAPA's strict bail bar. But given unresolved questions about a key witness and more important witnesses yet to testify, it didn't grant bail itself, instead giving liberty to file a fresh bail application before the trial court, directing it to weigh the delay.
Lesson Learnt
Long pretrial detention without trial progress can eventually threaten a person's right to liberty even in serious terrorism cases, though a higher court may send the question back to the trial court for a fresh decision rather than granting bail outright.