Ishwar Singh Chhikara vs. Naresh Kumar & Anr.
Background
Ishwar Singh Chhikara says he owns floors of a building in Uttam Nagar, New Delhi, with ownership recognised under the PM-UDAY scheme for unauthorised colonies. In his civil suit, the occupant Naresh Kumar told the trial court on 16 August 2024 that he was a tenant with no rights in the premises and promised to vacate within 20 days. He did not leave. His wife later claimed she owned the property through unregistered papers and said his statement had been made under pressure. An earlier contempt petition on the same promise had been withdrawn in March 2025, with liberty to pursue a proper remedy before the trial court.
Decision Breakdown
The Court found that Naresh Kumar had clearly admitted being a tenant and had promised to vacate. It rejected his excuses that he was pressured, misled or illiterate, noting that he made the statement in court with his own lawyer present, and that illiteracy alone does not mean he did not understand it. It called this a blatant attempt to go back on an undertaking. Even so, the Court said this second contempt petition could not continue: the first one had been withdrawn so that the owner could seek a remedy in the trial court, and he had since filed an application there under Order XII Rule 6 CPC (a request for a decision based on admissions), which was still pending. The petition was disposed of with liberty to pursue his remedies in accordance with law.
Lesson Learnt
A promise made to a court, such as an undertaking to vacate, is taken seriously, and claims of pressure or illiteracy will not easily undo it. But a person who withdraws a contempt case to pursue another remedy generally cannot later file a fresh contempt case on the same promise while that other remedy is still pending.