Jitendra @ Jitu Nainsingh Gehlot vs. Union of India & Anr.
Background
The petitioner was convicted with others for the 1994 robbery and murder of five women and two young children in a family home in Pune. He was sentenced to death, and the Bombay High Court and the Supreme Court upheld the sentence in 1999-2000. His mercy petition, filed in 2001, passed back and forth between the Union Home Ministry and the Maharashtra government for years, and records were even lost in a fire. In September 2016, the President commuted (reduced) his death sentence to life imprisonment, but with a condition that he stay in prison for the rest of his natural life with no further remission (early release) by any authority. He challenged that condition in the High Court.
Decision Breakdown
The Court dismissed the petition. It first held that it could hear the case in Delhi because the decision came from the President's office there. It accepted that the 15-year delay in deciding the mercy petition was inordinate and might by itself have justified commuting the death sentence. However, it found from the official file that the President knew about the delay, had sought the Attorney General's opinion (which favoured commutation), had also received the Home Ministry's view (which favoured rejection), and considered both. Relying on Supreme Court rulings, the Court held that the President has the power to commute a death sentence to imprisonment for the rest of natural life without remission. Since its role is judicial review of how the power was used, not an appeal on the outcome, it would not replace the President's decision with its own.
Lesson Learnt
Courts can review a President's or Governor's mercy decision only on limited grounds, such as whether relevant facts were considered. If the decision was made after weighing the relevant material, a court will not overturn it merely because it might have decided differently.