Jiya Lal vs. State
Background
In 2004, two men riding a scooter carrying Rs. 3 lakh were attacked in Delhi's Azadpur Mandi area; one was shot and the cash snatched. Based on a co-accused's disclosure statement, the appellant was arrested nearly two weeks later, accused of harbouring the robbers and sharing the loot; he was not named in the original complaint. The trial court convicted him along with the others.
Decision Breakdown
The High Court overturned the conviction entirely. The only witness identifying him in court had never seen him before, no formal identification parade was conducted, and the witness gave contradictory accounts. Co-accused statements implicating him were legally inadmissible, and no stolen money or weapon was recovered from him. Mere suspicion, however strong, cannot substitute for proof beyond reasonable doubt.
Lesson Learnt
A person cannot be convicted based only on a courtroom identification by a stranger-witness with no prior identification parade, or on a co-accused's statement to police.