Karan Kapoor vs. State (Govt of NCT of Delhi) & Ors.
Background
The petitioner had filed an application in a criminal trial court under Section 175(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), the provision under which a Magistrate can order the police to investigate a complaint. Arguments on this application were heard three times, and each time the matter was put off for orders. After the third hearing on 31 October 2026, the trial court fixed 28 January 2027 for its order. The petitioner asked the High Court to direct a quicker decision.
Decision Breakdown
The Court noted that this was not a slow trial caused by missing witnesses or forensic reports. It was a single application on which arguments had been heard repeatedly without an order being passed, and it found the trial court's practice of listing the matter "for orders or clarifications" to be mechanical. Although the criminal procedure law sets no time limit for deciding such applications, the Court drew guidance from Section 258(1) BNSS, which asks a Sessions Court to give judgment within 30 days of arguments (extendable to 45 days with recorded reasons). Leaving a matter undecided for long after arguments, it said, erodes public confidence in the justice system. The State did not oppose the petition. The trial court was directed to decide the application within 15 days, and a copy of the judgment was sent to all Principal District and Sessions Judges so that Delhi criminal courts pronounce final judgments within 30-45 days of arguments and other orders within 15 days.
Lesson Learnt
Once a court has heard arguments, it is expected to give its decision within a reasonable time. If a lower court keeps postponing an order without good reason, a party can ask the High Court for a direction to decide promptly.