Lal Chand @ Golu vs. The State of NCT of Delhi
Background
The applicant was accused of murder in a 2023 case from Police Station Ranjeet Nagar. According to the police, a quarrel began at night over a wrongly parked scooter blocking a car, after which the applicant and a co-accused rode off with the scooter owner, pushed the scooter over and beat him, and he was later declared dead in hospital. The defence said the three were friends and the scooter skidded because the deceased was drunk. The only claimed eyewitness had not come to court to finish his evidence since September 2025, even though non-bailable warrants (arrest orders to secure attendance) had been issued.
Decision Breakdown
The Court viewed CCTV footage played by the prosecution and noted that even the prosecution accepted the deceased was under the influence of liquor while driving the scooter that allegedly skidded. It also noted that the eyewitness had repeatedly failed to appear, even after the investigating officer assured the Court in July 2026 that he would come on a fixed date. Holding that the accused cannot be kept in jail endlessly, the Court granted regular bail on a personal bond of Rs. 15,000 with one surety. It made clear that the trial court must decide the facts independently, without being influenced by this order.
Lesson Learnt
When a trial stalls because a key prosecution witness keeps failing to appear, an undertrial cannot be kept in custody without end, even in a serious case. Bail observations do not decide guilt; the trial court still assesses the evidence on its own.