Naresh v. State of Haryana
Background
On the night of 17.04.2011, two widows, Suman and Shakuntla, were killed in village Ranila, District Bhiwani, Haryana. The FIR, lodged by a village panch who had not seen the crime, named Naresh, alleging he had attacked them with a danda (stick) because he believed they were involved in prostitution; a co-accused, Subhash, was arrested too. At trial every private witness, including the informant, the only adult eyewitness and Suman's young son, turned hostile, yet the trial court sentenced both men to death; the High Court acquitted Subhash but upheld Naresh's murder conviction (commuting death to life imprisonment), mainly because his name appeared in the FIR.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court allowed the appeals and acquitted Naresh of all charges (murder, house-trespass, indignity to corpses and destroying evidence), ordering his release and refund of fine and setting aside the compensation he had been told to pay. It held that the FIR (itself hearsay) and police statements of witnesses who later disowned them cannot be used as substantive evidence of guilt or motive, as Section 162 CrPC forbids this. The danda could not have caused the fatal cut wounds, the gandasi (sharp weapon) surfaced only through a second "disclosure" recorded after the post-mortem, forensic tests could not link any blood to the victims, and several circumstances were never put to Naresh to explain. Applying the "five golden principles" for circumstantial evidence and the principle of parity (like cases must be decided alike), the Court found the evidence against Naresh no stronger than that on which Subhash had been acquitted, and that suspicion, however grave, cannot replace proof. It also recommended that the District Legal Services Authority, Bhiwani consider victim compensation for the families of the two women.
Lesson Learnt
A murder conviction must rest on evidence the law actually allows; an FIR or statements made to police that witnesses later deny in court cannot by themselves prove guilt. Where two accused face the same kind of evidence, courts cannot acquit one and convict the other, and even when an accused is acquitted, victims' families can still seek state compensation.