Pankaj vs. State of Govt. of NCT of Delhi & Anr.
Background
Following a minor traffic collision between strangers, the petitioner allegedly struck the other driver's head with a helmet, causing him to lose consciousness; injuries were later certified as simple. The petitioner had already secured regular bail, and the victim signed an affidavit confirming a voluntary settlement, reaffirmed in person before the Court.
Decision Breakdown
Applying settled tests for quashing on settlement, the Court weighed the sudden, unplanned nature of the scuffle, the petitioner's clean record, and the genuinely voluntary settlement. Finding conviction now remote and continued prosecution an "empty formality," it quashed the FIR, directing the petitioner to pay Rs. 10,000 in costs to the Delhi High Court Legal Services Committee.
Lesson Learnt
Even a serious-sounding charge can be quashed where the victim has genuinely settled, injuries were minor, and continuing would serve no purpose, though the beneficiary may still be made to pay costs.