Raju Shantaram Koli v. The State of Maharashtra (with connected appeal)
Background
The appellant was convicted of the rape and murder of a 12-year-old victim and sentenced to life imprisonment on each count, with the trial court directing the two life sentences run consecutively (one after the other) rather than concurrently. The Bombay High Court upheld this, and a separate writ petition seeking concurrent sentences was also rejected.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court held that consecutive life sentences for offences tried together in a single trial are legally impermissible, following the binding Constitution Bench ruling in Muthuramalingam v. State. "Imprisonment for life" means imprisonment for the remainder of one's natural life, so directing two life sentences to run one after another is a logical impossibility: a person has only one life to serve. The Court set aside the consecutive-sentence direction and instead directed the sentences be "superimposed" on each other, clarifying that remission or commutation granted on one sentence does not automatically extend to the other.
Lesson Learnt
When a person is convicted of multiple offences in one trial and given more than one life sentence, those sentences cannot be stacked to run one after another: they run together, though forgiveness granted on one does not automatically release the prisoner from the other.