Sandeep vs. The State (NCT of Delhi) & Anr.
Background
Police in Karol Bagh caught a man named Sumit on 13 June 2026 with two pistols. Based on Sumit's confession, police said the applicant, Sandeep, and others had planned to rob gold articles. Sandeep was arrested about two days later and a pistol was allegedly recovered from him. He was charged under Section 310(4) BNS (preparation to commit dacoity, which is robbery by a group of five or more), other BNS sections, and the Arms Act, and had been in custody since 15 June 2026.
Decision Breakdown
The State opposed bail, relying on call records linking Sandeep with Sumit and on CCTV footage said to show Sandeep fleeing. The Court held that call detail records alone cannot show a crime unless the content of the calls is known. It said that recovery of a weapon, on a first look, does not by itself prove preparation for dacoity. After seeing the CCTV footage, the Court found it showed Sandeep talking on his phone, dusting his scooter seat, covering his face against the heat, putting on his helmet and driving away, which did not look like fleeing. The Court granted regular bail on a personal bond of Rs. 20,000 with one surety, and said the trial court must still take its own view on the evidence.
Lesson Learnt
Phone contact between two people is not, by itself, proof that they planned a crime together. Courts deciding bail look closely at what the evidence shows, and may watch CCTV footage themselves rather than accept the police description of it.