Santhosh Kumar N.P. v. State-Station House Officer, Kadirur Police, Tellicherry, Kannur District & Another
Background
The appellant and the complainant entered a personal relationship in the 1990s, went through a marriage-like ceremony in 1996, and lived together until 2003. The complainant admitted she learned within about six months that the appellant already had a wife and children, yet continued the relationship for years. After it ended, she filed a private criminal complaint years later alleging rape, cheating, and bigamy. Lower courts and the Kerala High Court refused to discharge him.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court discharged the appellant, holding none of the alleged offences was even prima facie made out. The relationship was consensual between adults that later soured, not deceit vitiating consent, since the complainant knew of the prior marriage early on and chose to continue cohabiting for years regardless. The cheating charge failed for lack of any property or valuable security obtained by deception, and the bigamy-related charges failed since she couldn't have been "made to believe" she was the lawful wife once she knew the truth. The Court flagged a "disturbing trend" of consensual relationships that end badly being retrospectively recast as criminal cases.
Lesson Learnt
A relationship that was genuinely consensual at the time cannot later be converted into a criminal case simply because it ended badly: criminal law requires proof that consent was obtained by actual deceit at the time, not hindsight dissatisfaction with how the relationship turned out.