Sau. Kamalbai Waman Patil v. The State of Maharashtra
Background
A woman died from severe burn injuries, allegedly set on fire by her husband's family amid dowry-related harassment. Four family members were jointly tried for murder on a theory of common intention; the trial court acquitted all four, citing inconsistent dying declarations and evidence gaps, but the Bombay High Court reversed and convicted only the mother-in-law.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court restored the acquittal. Since all four were charged jointly on a "common intention" theory with no separate standalone charge against the mother-in-law alone, convicting just her for the same joint offence after the others were acquitted effectively invented a new, unframed accusation. The High Court had also wrongly relied on a single uncorroborated dying declaration while ignoring that a key eyewitness was never examined, and wrongly held the accused's silence against her before the prosecution had even made out a prima facie case.
Lesson Learnt
When several people are jointly charged with murder on a "common intention" theory, a court cannot acquit all but one and then convict the remaining person alone for the same joint offence; an accused's silence can only be held against them after the prosecution has independently proved its case.