Sharmishtha vs. The State of NCT of Delhi
Background
This appeal arose from the same 1998 dying-declaration incident involving a bride who suffered fatal burns at her matrimonial home, but was a separate Sessions Case against another sister-in-law, Sharmishtha, convicted of murder and cruelty and sentenced to life.
Decision Breakdown
The Court rejected challenges based on delay in recording the dying declaration, absence of a doctor's endorsement, a hostile witness, and a suicide theory, holding minor gaps don't undermine an otherwise consistent declaration, a doctor's signature is a caution not a strict requirement, and no evidence supported suicide. It upheld the murder conviction but set aside the separate cruelty conviction for lack of specific evidence, directing her to surrender.
Lesson Learnt
Courts don't discard a dying declaration over small inconsistencies or a missing doctor's signature: what matters is consistency on core facts; but each separate charge still needs its own specific proof.