Subhasindu Das v. Bacchu Ranjan Das
Background
Some members of Sri Guru Sangha, a charitable society with its central Ashram in Kolkata, filed a suit in 2012 under Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure (a special suit about how a public charity is run) seeking removal of office-bearers and a scheme for managing the Sangha. While the suit was pending, the Trial Court appointed a Special Officer to oversee the Sangha; after allegations against her, it called for and considered her written explanation, then on 07.06.2022, on a joint application of the parties, removed her and set up a 13-member ad hoc committee with quarterly reporting and annual audits. The Calcutta High Court stayed that arrangement, and later also overturned the Trial Court's refusal (09.09.2025) to add two other devotees, Bachhu Ranjan Das and Bablu Das, as parties to the suit.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court allowed all the appeals and set aside the High Court's orders. It held that the Trial Court was competent to arrange interim management, that a Special Officer has no vested right to stay in the post, and that she had in fact been given a chance to explain herself, so the High Court's supervisory interference under Article 227 (meant only for patent jurisdictional errors, perversity or grave injustice) was unwarranted. On the impleadment question, it held that even though a Section 92 suit is "representative" in nature, not every devotee or member gets an automatic right to be added as a party; under Order I Rule 10(2) CPC an applicant must show why their presence is necessary or proper, and general allegations of mismanagement are not enough. The Court declined to appoint a new administrator or committee itself, leaving fresh allegations about the ad hoc committee's finances to be raised before the Trial Court, and expressed no view on the merits of the suit.
Lesson Learnt
Being a member or devotee of a public charity does not by itself entitle you to join a court case about its management: you must show specifically why your participation is needed. Higher courts should not lightly upset interim arrangements a trial court has made after giving the affected person a fair chance to be heard.