Tinku vs. Narcotics Control Bureau
Background
The applicant sought regular bail in an NDPS case where 5.103 kg of amphetamine was recovered in a raid, part of a larger operation involving different drugs. The prosecution's case was that Tinku coordinated an international drug-peddling cartel involving Indian and African nationals. Tinku argued the only evidence against him was co-accused disclosure statements, and that incriminating WhatsApp chats produced by the NCB belonged to a different person ("Manav Bidla"), not him.
Decision Breakdown
The Court found that the mobile number used by "Manav Bidla" in the WhatsApp chats was listed as Tinku's own "alternate contact number" in his KYC form, and that SIM cards for both numbers were recovered from the same seized phone, showing, at least prima facie, that both identities were the same person. Because the case involved a commercial quantity of drugs, the stricter bail test under Section 37 of the NDPS Act applied. Finding the WhatsApp evidence (orders, acknowledgments, and payments for contraband) went well beyond mere co-accused statements, the Court held the threshold for bail was not met and dismissed the application.
Lesson Learnt
In serious drug cases involving commercial quantities, bail is much harder to get, and digital evidence like WhatsApp chats, even where identity is disputed, can be pieced together with other records (like KYC forms) to link an accused to an alias.