Union of India v. Arif Nisar @ Sahil
Background
After posters linked to the banned group Jaish-e-Mohammad appeared in Srinagar, the J&K Police registered an FIR at Nowgam on 19.10.2025 and found that several accused were doctors, some working at Al-Falah University, Faridabad; weapons, ammunition and large quantities of explosives were then recovered in Faridabad. One accused, Umer-un-Nabi, escaped in an explosives-laden car and carried out a bomb blast near the Red Fort Metro Station on 10.11.2025, which the NIA is investigating (the "Lal Qila Blast Case"), and Haryana Police registered another FIR at Dhauj, Faridabad on 19.11.2025. The Central Government handed both the Haryana and J&K cases to the NIA, and the Union of India asked the Supreme Court to move them to the NIA Special Court at Patiala House, New Delhi, and club them with the blast case; the accused opposed the clubbing.
Decision Breakdown
The Court allowed the transfer petitions, moving the J&K and Haryana cases to the NIA Special Court at Patiala House, New Delhi, and directing that all three cases be clubbed (tried together). It reasoned that the cases involve common accused, common witnesses and overlapping evidence, so separate trials in different States would mean duplicated evidence and a risk of conflicting verdicts, and repeatedly moving accused persons between States (with some accused still absconding) posed serious security risks. The accused relied on State (NCT of Delhi) v. Khimji Bhai Jadeja, arguing the cases were not part of the "same transaction"; the Court distinguished it because the NIA's case is not that the incidents are one transaction but that they are linked by a larger conspiracy against the country's security and sovereignty. It also followed its earlier order in NIA v. Rahul @ Faisal Karim Masud (04.06.2026), which similarly transferred and clubbed cases before the same court.
Lesson Learnt
Where crimes in different States are alleged to be part of one larger terror conspiracy with common accused, witnesses and evidence, the Supreme Court can bring them together for a single trial before one Special Court, to avoid duplicated proceedings, conflicting judgments and security risks, even if the incidents are not strictly one "transaction."