V. Gopalakrishnan v. The State of Kerala
Background
A government officer who rose to Sub-Registrar faced a vigilance case alleging he and his family acquired assets far exceeding his known lawful income during an eight-year check period. The trial court convicted him in 2009; the Kerala High Court upheld the conviction in 2025 while reducing the sentence citing his age and case delay. He appealed the conviction itself.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court held the prosecution had proved disproportionate assets amounting to over 51% of his known income, far above the roughly 10% margin of error courts have historically allowed. Even giving him the benefit of every disputed figure he raised, unexplained assets still exceeded 26%. Once the prosecution establishes disproportion, the burden shifts to the public servant to satisfactorily account for the excess, a burden he failed to discharge with only vague estimates and an unverified personal notebook.
Lesson Learnt
Once the prosecution shows a significant gap between a public servant's known income and actual wealth, the burden shifts to the accused to prove legitimate sources with real documentary evidence: vague estimates will not suffice.