Vishnu Prasad vs. State of NCT of Delhi
Background
A neighbour was accused of sexually assaulting a six-year-old girl in 2021 by inserting his finger into her private part, and convicted of the most serious POCSO offence (aggravated penetrative sexual assault), sentenced to 20 years.
Decision Breakdown
The Court explained POCSO distinguishes "penetrative" assault (minimum 20 years) from non-penetrative "sexual assault" (minimum 5 years). Reviewing testimony and medical evidence, it found penetration not proved beyond reasonable doubt, set aside the 20-year conviction, but upheld the lesser offence and related charges, resulting in a 5-year sentence (of which over 4 years had already been served).
Lesson Learnt
In child sexual assault cases, the law distinguishes actual penetration from mere contact, and this distinction drastically changes the punishment: the prosecution must prove penetration specifically for the harshest sentence to apply.