Ajay Aggarwal vs. Bank of Baroda Erstwhile E Vijaya Bank & Ors.
Background
Vijaya Bank (now Bank of Baroda) had a recovery certificate from 2000 for about Rs. 1.74 crore against a company and others, and a large plot of land in Goa was put up for auction in December 2024. Ajay Aggarwal, who said he was an intending buyer, filed three objections claiming the sale notice described the land wrongly because parts had already been sold to others. The e-auction went ahead on 21 January 2025 and his objections were rejected afterwards. The Debts Recovery Tribunal and then the Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal (DRAT) both held that he could not appeal because he was not a "person aggrieved".
Decision Breakdown
The Court dismissed the petition. Under Section 30 of the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act, only a "person aggrieved" (someone whose own legal rights or interests are harmed) can appeal against a Recovery Officer's order. The petitioner was not the borrower, owner or tenant, had no right in the property, did not bid and did not even deposit the earnest money (the deposit bidders pay to show they are serious). The Court said a hope that he might have bought the land at a better price is only an imaginary injury, and allowing such challenges would let anyone delay auctions. Finding that he had abused the process of law, it imposed costs of Rs. 1,00,000, split between the Army Welfare War Widows Fund and the Delhi High Court Bar Association, payable within three weeks.
Lesson Learnt
Saying you planned to bid is not enough to challenge a bank's recovery auction. Only a person whose own rights or interests are affected can do so, and courts may impose heavy costs on people who file objections only to stall a sale.