Vayuu Propmart Pvt. Ltd. vs. UBA Realtech Pvt. Ltd. and Ors. and connected matters
Background
A bank gave a company a Rs. 30 crore term loan in 2012, and two other companies, UBA Realtech and Nuray Realtech, mortgaged land in Gurgaon as guarantors. The loan turned bad, the bank demanded about Rs. 32.17 crore in 2014, and the borrower later went through insolvency, where a resolution plan dealing with the bank's claim was approved in 2024. About nine years after its demand notice, the bank issued a sale notice claiming about Rs. 137.78 crore, and the land was auctioned to Vayuu Propmart. When the guarantors appealed to the Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal (DRAT), it asked them to deposit only 30% of the Rs. 32.17 crore in the 2014 demand notice, rather than a share of the much larger later figure. Vayuu Propmart, the auction buyer, challenged this.
Decision Breakdown
Under Section 18 of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (SARFAESI Act), a borrower appealing to the DRAT must first deposit 50% of the debt due, which the DRAT can reduce to no less than 25% for written reasons. The auction buyer argued that, under the Supreme Court's ruling in Sidha Neelkanth Paper v. Prudent ARC, the deposit should have been based on the higher, later amount. The High Court held that its supervisory power under Article 227 of the Constitution only checks whether a tribunal stayed within its authority, and a merely wrong decision is not enough for it to step in. The DRAT had acted within its power under Section 18, so whether it applied Sidha Neelkanth correctly was not something the High Court would re-examine here. It also said the DRAT's remarks were made while deciding interim applications and are not a final view on the appeal, and dismissed both petitions.
Lesson Learnt
The High Court's supervisory power over tribunals is limited: it steps in when a tribunal goes beyond its powers or acts perversely, not merely because a party thinks the tribunal got the law wrong. Observations made while deciding a deposit or other interim question do not decide the final appeal.