Delhi Tamil Education Association (Regd.) vs. Government of NCT of Delhi & Anr. and connected matters
Background
The Delhi Tamil Education Association runs seven government-aided Tamil minority schools in Delhi, where the government pays 95% of staff salaries through grant-in-aid (public funding). After winning an earlier case that let it fill vacant posts without the Directorate of Education's (DoE's) prior approval, it recruited 100 teaching and non-teaching staff in 2024-25. In November 2025, the DoE refused grant-in-aid for all 100 appointments, raising objections about qualifications, vacancies and the selection process. The Association challenged that refusal, and a group of the new employees, who had worked without pay, separately sought their salaries.
Decision Breakdown
The Court held that Article 30(1) of the Constitution lets a minority school choose its own staff, but the State can still insist on the prescribed qualifications before paying for them with public money. It held that Assistant Teachers in aided schools are governed by the 1989 Recruitment Rules, and a B.Ed. degree without the required JBT/BTC primary teacher training does not meet that requirement. The school was free to recruit Principals directly without first promoting from within, and the DoE's own refusal to send its nominees to the Selection Committees could not, by itself, invalidate the selections. Because the DoE had rejected all 100 appointments together, even though its objections differed from person to person, the Court set aside that order and directed a senior officer to decide each appointment separately within twelve weeks, after hearing the school and the employee. On salaries, the Court held that a clause postponing pay until grant-in-aid arrives does not cancel the school's own liability to pay for work already done, and that a refusal of grant-in-aid does not by itself end anyone's employment. Both petitions were partly allowed.
Lesson Learnt
A minority school can choose its staff, but government funding for their salaries depends on meeting the official qualification rules. Employees who have worked can still claim pay from the school that hired them, even if the government refuses to fund their posts.