The Managing Committee of The Pinnacle School vs. The Director of Education & Anr. and connected matters
Background
Bindu Khanna joined The Pinnacle School in 1994, claiming appointment as a Trained Graduate Teacher (TGT) and later promotion to Post Graduate Teacher (PGT) in 2006, entitling her to higher pay. The School's own records were inconsistent across staff designations. The Director of Education accepted her claim in 2015, ordering about Rs. 16.72 lakh in arrears; the School challenged this, while Khanna separately filed a connected contempt case alleging non-compliance with an earlier pay direction.
Decision Breakdown
The Court found the Director had cherry-picked an early staff statement while ignoring later records and appraisal forms where Khanna described herself as TGT, with no formal promotion order to PGT ever issued. It held a post requires a proper appointment or selection process, not just a register entry, and set aside the Director's order, remanding for a narrower recalculation of pay owed as an Assistant Teacher placed in the TGT grade from 2003. On the connected contempt case, the School had already deposited the disputed money with the Court registry, so no further contempt action was warranted. Money already paid to Khanna during the case need not be refunded, since the inconsistency was the School's own doing.
Lesson Learnt
An employer's own inconsistent paperwork can create real disputes over an employee's actual job title and pay, but a stray HR record entry alone does not prove a promotion happened; a proper appointment process is still required.