Dunar Foods Limited vs. Ankit Vats Trading as AVJK Foods LLP and connected matters

Rectification Petition (Commercial IPD, Trade Mark) · CNR No. DLHC010492622024Decided 17 Nov 2026New Delhi Bench
C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 158/2024, C.O. (COMM.IPD-TM) 203/2024CNR: DLHC010492622024
Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav

Background

Dunar Foods, a large basmati rice maker and exporter, has used the brand name NAWAJISH for rice and had it registered since 2007. In 2024 it found Ankit Vats (trading as AVJK Foods LLP) selling basmati rice in similar packaging under a near-identical name with a letter "N" logo, registered in 2017 on a "proposed to be used" basis (meaning no actual use had been shown at the time of applying). Each side asked the High Court to cancel the other's trade mark registration.

Decision Breakdown

The Court rejected Ankit Vats's objection that Dunar Foods could not bring the case because its assets were under attachment by the Enforcement Directorate, holding that an attachment only stops the owner from dealing with the property, not from protecting it in court. Comparing the two marks, the Court found them identical in sound and look, for the same goods, and held that the "N" logo and swapping "J" for "Z" did not prevent confusion among buyers. NAWAJISH is a coined word, not a dictionary word, and Ankit Vats gave no explanation for picking it, so the Court found its adoption dishonest. Relying on the rule that a prior user's rights are stronger than a later registration, the Court held the registration was barred under Sections 9(2)(a) and 11(3)(a) of the Act and cancelled Ankit Vats's registration. Ankit Vats's own petition to cancel Dunar Foods's mark was dismissed.

Lesson Learnt

Getting a trade mark registered does not protect a business that copies a name someone else was already using. Small changes to spelling or a logo will not save a copied brand if ordinary shoppers could still be confused.

IP LawSupreme Court of India

M/S The Supreme Industries Limited v. M/S Supremo India Private Limited (with connected Transfer Petition)

The Supreme Court noted both sides agreed only that the related suits should be tried together, while disagreeing on which city. Without ruling on the merits of either side's preference, the Court transferred both suits to a neutral forum, the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad, directing both courts to transfer the plaints and the parties to appear there.

Decided 28 Oct 2026Read case
Intellectual Property LawDelhi High Court

Japan Tobacco Inc. & Anr. vs. The Central Warehouse & Anr.

The Court held that the petitioners had not established that they were the "first owner" of the original artistic work, which was a precondition for expunging the impugned registration. Because that point was not established, the Court considered the argument about alleged violation of Section 45(1) of the Act and Rule 70 of the Copyright Rules, 2013 to be academic and unpersuasive. It also held that the parties' authorities relied on were not relevant to this analysis. The petition was dismissed, with an express clarification that the observations about the earlier suit (CS(COMM) 644/2018) do not decide the merits of that suit.

Decided 5 Oct 2026Read case
Intellectual Property LawSupreme Court of India

I.S.D.S. Private Limited v. M/s Khemka Food Products Pvt. Ltd.

This is a referral order, not a final judgment. The Court found a conflict between two of its earlier decisions, Kandla Export Corporation v. OCI Corporation and Jaycee Housing v. Registrar, Orissa High Court, on this question. It referred the matter to a larger bench and stayed the underlying commercial suit until the reference is decided.

Decided 21 Sept 2026Read case
Intellectual Property LawDelhi High Court

ADS Spirits Pvt. Ltd. vs. The Registrar of Trade Marks

The Division Bench held that publication of a trademark under the Trade Marks Act only happens after an application is formally "accepted," and this application had not yet reached that stage. It agreed with the Single Judge's approach of sending the matter back to the trademark authorities for fresh, correct examination rather than the High Court deciding registrability itself, especially since the Registry was already re-examining the application per the earlier order. Finding no legal error, the appeal was dismissed.

Decided 15 Sept 2026Read case
Intellectual Property LawDelhi High Court

ITC Limited vs. The Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs & Ors. and connected matters

The High Court held that although the Controller's order deciding the two interlocutory petitions was framed somewhat confusingly, there was no real violation of fair procedure: ITC had been given adequate opportunities to respond at every stage, and the Patentee's later written submissions did not introduce anything genuinely new or unfair. The writ petition was dismissed alongside the connected appeal, with the Court finding no legal infirmity in how the patent opposition process was conducted.

Decided 10 Sept 2026Read case
Intellectual Property LawDelhi High Court

Hindustan Unilever Limited vs. Kwick Living (I) Private Limited

The Division Bench found that hoardings for the disputed advertising campaign had been put up in Delhi before the lawsuit was filed, and that Kwick Living itself had a GST-registered principal place of business in Delhi's Naraina Industrial Area and admitted selling its products there. On this basis, the Court held that Delhi's territorial jurisdiction was clearly established under Section 20(a) and 20(c) of the Civil Procedure Code. It allowed HUL to formally amend its plaint to record these two facts and sent the case back to the Single Judge to decide the interim injunction application on its merits, directing an expedited hearing.

Decided 2 Sept 2026Read case
Dunar Foods Limited vs. Ankit Vats Trading as AVJK Foods…