Dunar Foods Limited vs. Ankit Vats Trading as AVJK Foods LLP and connected matters
Background
Dunar Foods, a large basmati rice maker and exporter, has used the brand name NAWAJISH for rice and had it registered since 2007. In 2024 it found Ankit Vats (trading as AVJK Foods LLP) selling basmati rice in similar packaging under a near-identical name with a letter "N" logo, registered in 2017 on a "proposed to be used" basis (meaning no actual use had been shown at the time of applying). Each side asked the High Court to cancel the other's trade mark registration.
Decision Breakdown
The Court rejected Ankit Vats's objection that Dunar Foods could not bring the case because its assets were under attachment by the Enforcement Directorate, holding that an attachment only stops the owner from dealing with the property, not from protecting it in court. Comparing the two marks, the Court found them identical in sound and look, for the same goods, and held that the "N" logo and swapping "J" for "Z" did not prevent confusion among buyers. NAWAJISH is a coined word, not a dictionary word, and Ankit Vats gave no explanation for picking it, so the Court found its adoption dishonest. Relying on the rule that a prior user's rights are stronger than a later registration, the Court held the registration was barred under Sections 9(2)(a) and 11(3)(a) of the Act and cancelled Ankit Vats's registration. Ankit Vats's own petition to cancel Dunar Foods's mark was dismissed.
Lesson Learnt
Getting a trade mark registered does not protect a business that copies a name someone else was already using. Small changes to spelling or a logo will not save a copied brand if ordinary shoppers could still be confused.