M/S The Supreme Industries Limited v. M/S Supremo India Private Limited (with connected Transfer Petition)
Background
Two companies were locked in a trademark dispute over use of the mark "SUPREME," each having filed its own suit in a different city (Indore and Delhi) accusing the other of infringement and passing off. Each filed a Transfer Petition asking the other's suit be moved to its preferred city.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court noted both sides agreed only that the related suits should be tried together, while disagreeing on which city. Without ruling on the merits of either side's preference, the Court transferred both suits to a neutral forum, the City Civil Court, Ahmedabad, directing both courts to transfer the plaints and the parties to appear there.
Lesson Learnt
When the same commercial dispute spawns parallel lawsuits in different courts, the Supreme Court can consolidate them into a single proceeding at a neutral venue rather than favoring either litigant's home turf.