Mangala Bhimrao Ingle v. The Additional Commissioner, Amravati Division & Ors.
Background
A woman who had a third child in 2014 later won a 2022 Sarpanch election in Maharashtra; her election was set aside under a state law disqualifying candidates with more than two living children, a type of law the Supreme Court had upheld in its 2003 ruling in Javed v. State of Haryana on grounds of preventing a "population explosion."
Decision Breakdown
The Court held that while Javed was validly decided in 2003, its underlying demographic premise has since collapsed: India's fertility rate has fallen from roughly 3.0 to 1.9, now below replacement level, meaning the country faces an ageing-population problem, not a population explosion. The Court also found the reasoning independently troubling: such laws disproportionately burden women, whose reproductive decisions are often controlled by husbands, and have driven forced abortions and denial of paternity to dodge disqualification, compelling an unconscionable choice against Article 21's reproductive autonomy. Rather than deciding the issue itself, the Court referred Javed for reconsideration by a larger bench, while letting the appellant remain in office pending final disposal.
Lesson Learnt
A law valid when enacted can become constitutionally questionable once the real-world conditions justifying it disappear: courts will revisit old precedents when their factual premise no longer matches reality, particularly where women's reproductive autonomy is at stake.