M/s. Shivani Handlooms (WCIS) Ltd. vs. Union of India

First Appeal from Order (Commercial) · 2026:DHC:8026-DBDecided 16 Sept 2026New Delhi Bench
FAO (COMM) 119/2025CNR: DLHC010288072025
Justice C. Hari Shankar · Justice Vinod Kumar

Background

A small-scale blanket manufacturer had a government supply contract with the Ministry of Defence to deliver about 35,897 blankets to multiple consignees. A batch sent to Pune (about 7,660 blankets) was rejected as substandard and taken back by the manufacturer, while it claimed the remaining ~28,237 blankets delivered elsewhere were accepted and paid for only in part. An arbitrator awarded the manufacturer roughly Rs. 48 lakh (unpaid balance plus interest) and rejected the government's counterclaim for damages, but never actually addressed the government's specific claim for liquidated damages arising from the manufacturer's failure to ever replace the rejected Pune consignment as the contract required. A District Judge set aside the whole award on this basis, and the manufacturer appealed.

Decision Breakdown

The High Court agreed that the arbitrator's total silence on the Pune-related damages claim was a serious gap, since the contract clearly obligated the manufacturer to replace any rejected, defective stock, and it was undisputed that no replacement was ever supplied. Because all the supplies (Pune and elsewhere) arose from the very same single contract, the Court held it was not possible to simply keep the "good" parts of the award and discard only the Pune-related portion: courts reviewing arbitration awards can only sever a bad part from a good part in limited situations, and cannot themselves calculate the damages the arbitrator failed to determine. The entire award was therefore correctly set aside, and the appeal was dismissed.

Lesson Learnt

If an arbitrator completely fails to rule on one connected part of a dispute (like a counterclaim for damages tied to the very same contract), the resulting award can be struck down in full: courts will not, and generally cannot, patch the gap themselves by calculating the missing amount.

Arbitration & Commercial LawSupreme Court of India

Shreeram Builders v. Upendra Kantilal Thanawala & Ors.

The Supreme Court upheld setting aside the award, though for more precise reasons, holding that stamp duty classification alone wasn't decisive, but the arbitrators had exceeded their authority by effectively rewriting the contract: the price was never fixed, full consideration was never paid by deadline, and the arbitrators invented an unexplained price multiplier and damages the contract never provided for. Invoking its Article 142 power to do complete justice, the Court ordered the owners to refund all amounts received from the builder with 9% interest, since they never returned the payments after terminating the deal.

Decided 29 Oct 2026Read case
Arbitration & Commercial LawDelhi High Court

M/S S.R. Ashok & Associates vs. Delhi Development Authority & Anr. and connected matters

The Court rejected the time-bar argument since the arbitration invocation was a single continuing one and DDA had consented to delays while participating throughout. It found no error apparent on the face of either award, upholding both and making them enforceable court decrees.

Decided 28 Oct 2026Read case
Arbitration & Commercial LawDelhi High Court

Axis Finance Ltd vs. Mr Nikhil A V & Ors.

The Court granted leave and liberty to withdraw and dismissed the petition without ruling on the underlying dispute.

Decided 28 Oct 2026Read case
Arbitration & Commercial LawDelhi High Court

MMTC Limited vs. Aust Grain Exports Pty Ltd

The Court rejected MMTC's procedural and compensation arguments but found one real flaw: the tribunal had expressly rejected the exporter's claim for interest on the refunded guarantee (since the contract barred it), yet then awarded that very interest anyway, a direct, unexplained contradiction. The Court struck out only that contradictory portion as severable, leaving the rest of the award intact.

Decided 28 Oct 2026Read case
Arbitration & Commercial LawDelhi High Court

Chief Electoral Officer & Anr. vs. M/S Mahlakshmi Light House

The government argued the arbitrator ignored an internal inquiry suggesting inflated bills. The Court held returning officers who checked goods at the time gave more reliable evidence than a later inquiry report, and this specific objection was never raised before the single judge, so couldn't be raised for the first time on appeal. The appeal was dismissed.

Decided 28 Oct 2026Read case
Arbitration & Commercial LawDelhi High Court

Utracon Corporation Pte Ltd vs. Ucon PT Structural System Private Limited (formerly Utracon Structural Systems Private Limited) & Ors.

The defendant applied to refer the whole suit to arbitration, arguing the real dispute was about contractual rights to use the marks between identified parties (not a trademark registration or grant dispute, which can't be arbitrated), flowing from a single composite transaction. The Court agreed: the arbitration clause's existence was undisputed, the dispute was essentially contractual, and since the plaintiff itself had pleaded that the other defendants formed a "single economic unit" with the main defendant and derived their rights "through" it, their claims couldn't be separated out either; any question of whether they were bound by the arbitration clause was for the arbitrator to decide. The Court referred the whole suit to arbitration and disposed of it, expressly offering no opinion on the merits.

Decided 28 Oct 2026Read case
M/s. Shivani Handlooms (WCIS) Ltd. vs. Union of India