Neycer (India) Ltd. v. GMB Ceramics Ltd.
Background
Under a 1986 agreement, Neycer gave technical know-how and assistance to GMB to set up a ceramics plant in Orissa; the plant was commissioned about seven months late, and GMB went to arbitration. Before arbitration began, GMB's own telexes of October 1989 defined its claim as "over Rs. 2 crores" for all losses, but the Umpire (the deciding arbitrator) in 1999 awarded about Rs. 11.70 crore plus 15% interest. A Single Judge of the Calcutta High Court cut the award down to Rs. 2 crore in 2015, but a Division Bench restored the full award in 2018.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court set aside the Division Bench's judgment and restored the Single Judge's order limiting the award to Rs. 2 crore. It held that an arbitrator is a "creature of the contract and the reference" and cannot widen his own jurisdiction: once GMB itself limited its claim to Rs. 2 crore when appointing its arbitrator, it could not enlarge the claim by a later letter, and Neycer's participation on merits (while objecting all along) was not a waiver. The Court also agreed that the Rs. 2.03 crore awarded for brand-building advertising was speculative, since GMB's own audited accounts showed it actually spent only about Rs. 35.3 lakh, and that the Umpire wrongly treated Neycer as an insurer of five years of GMB's profits and loan interest. Because Neycer had already paid Rs. 4 crore (Rs. 2 crore principal plus Rs. 2 crore interest) under interim orders, and the dispute had run nearly four decades, the Court directed that this sum be treated as full and final satisfaction of the award, with each side bearing its own costs.
Lesson Learnt
When you define the amount or scope of your claim while invoking arbitration, that definition binds you: an arbitrator cannot award more than what was actually referred. Damages must also be based on real evidence of loss, not hypothetical estimates, especially when actual figures are available.