WAPCOS Limited vs. M P Khaitan & Anr.
Background
The Ministry of Tourism appointed WAPCOS, a public sector company, to execute a convention centre project in Aizawl, Mizoram, and WAPCOS awarded the construction contract (worth about Rs. 30 crore) to the contractor M P Khaitan in 2022. About 90% of the work was done, but the contractor stopped work in August 2024 because bills worth about Rs. 2.66 crore were unpaid. WAPCOS had admitted these dues in letters, said the Ministry had not released funds, and had itself promised to foreclose (formally close early) the contract if it could not pay. The Arbitral Tribunal (the arbitrator deciding the dispute) ordered WAPCOS to issue a foreclosure certificate, take over the site and let the contractor remove its machinery, and it removed the Ministry from the case.
Decision Breakdown
The Court dismissed the appeal without costs. It explained that under Section 37(2)(b) a court can interfere with an arbitrator's interim order only if it is perverse, patently illegal or beyond the arbitrator's powers, and will not replace a plausible view with its own. WAPCOS argued that only it could foreclose under Clause 13 of the contract, but the Court said that clause empowers WAPCOS without forbidding the contractor from seeking foreclosure, read with Sections 51, 53, 54 and 55 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872, and noted the clause had not even been raised before the arbitrator. It also upheld the direction that WAPCOS take over the project and the decision to drop the Ministry, since the Ministry had not signed the contract and it was doubtful that the handing-over clause could bind it.
Lesson Learnt
When one side admits it owes money and does not pay for a long time, the other side may be allowed to bring the contract to an end even if the written contract gives that right expressly only to the paying side. Courts give arbitrators wide room on interim orders and will step in only for serious errors.