M/s Telecommunication Consultants India Limited vs. M/s Rajput Construction
Background
Telecommunication Consultants India Limited won a road-work tender in Madhya Pradesh and passed the work on to Rajput Construction on a back-to-back basis. A dispute arose, and a sole arbitrator (a private judge chosen under the contract) gave an award in 2018 without Rajput Construction taking part. Rajput Construction challenged the award in May 2019, saying it first got a copy through an RTI request in March 2019, and argued that the arbitrator had been appointed by one side alone. The Commercial Court set the award aside on that ground but never decided whether the challenge had been filed in time.
Decision Breakdown
The High Court explained that Section 34(3) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act allows three months from receipt of the award to challenge it, plus a further 30 days at most if there is good reason. Relying on Supreme Court rulings, it held that this limit is strict and the general power to excuse delay under Section 5 of the Limitation Act does not apply. The question whether the arbitrator's one-sided appointment broke Section 12(5) of the Act could be examined only if the challenge was first found to be within time. Because the Commercial Court skipped the time-limit question, its judgment was set aside and the case was sent back for fresh decision. The parties were told to appear before the Commercial Court on 14 December 2026, and that court was asked to decide quickly since the award dates from 2018.
Lesson Learnt
A party wanting to challenge an arbitration award must act within three months of receiving it, with at most 30 more days for good reason. A court must decide whether the challenge is in time before looking at its merits, however strong those merits seem.