Marino Dredgeco Ltd. v. Board of Trustees of the Port of Kolkata
Background
Marino Dredgeco was hired by the Kolkata Port Trust to dredge a channel and basin for a pilot station at Sagar Island; the channel was put to use on 17.04.2001, and of the original contract value of Rs. 2,86,56,200, Rs. 2,79,32,865 had been paid. The contractor claimed payment for additional re-dredging, which became necessary due to heavy siltation, soil conditions that did not match the Port Trust's own data, and the absence of protective walls, and an arbitrator awarded the claim on 03.11.2003. A Single Judge of the Calcutta High Court upheld the award, but a Division Bench cut the amount to 50% and reduced interest to 6% from 08.02.2002 because the additional claim exceeded 70% of the original contract value, which it said "shocked the conscience" of the Court, even though it found the award was not perverse or unsupported by evidence.
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court set aside the Division Bench's judgment, allowed the contractor's appeal and restored the arbitral award in full; the Port Trust's appeal, which sought to set aside the entire award, was disposed of. It held that the "shocks the conscience" / conflict with "basic notions of morality or justice" ground cannot be invoked as mere lip service: there must be a substantive, blatant reason, and a bill simply being large is not one (relying on Ssangyong Engineering and Somdatt Builders). The High Court had not even examined the measurements and invoices the arbitrator relied on, and re-examining them would itself have been a forbidden review of the merits; nor could the award be partly cut down under Gayatri Balasamy, since the re-dredging claim was one inseparable whole. The Court added that a government body gets no special treatment in arbitration, and the lack of a completion certificate (which the Port Trust itself did not issue) did not defeat payment for work actually done.
Lesson Learnt
Courts have very limited power to interfere with arbitration awards; a judge cannot reduce an award just because the amount seems too high when the arbitrator relied on proper evidence. Government bodies stand on the same footing as private parties in arbitration.