M/s Eastman Cast and Forge Ltd. vs. M/s Exact Developers & Promotors Pvt. Ltd.
Background
In 2007 Eastman Cast and Forge booked six commercial units in a project called "The Ace" in Manesar, Gurugram, and paid the developer the full price of Rs. 4,07,81,000. The units were not handed over on time. In a settlement agreement signed in Delhi on 18 July 2023, the developer admitted its default and agreed to refund the full amount in five instalments, but it paid nothing. The buyer sued for recovery and asked the Court for a summary judgment, which is a decision given without a full trial when the other side has no real defence.
Decision Breakdown
The developer argued that only Gurugram courts could hear the case because the original builder-buyer agreement gave them exclusive jurisdiction. The Court disagreed: the buyer was suing on the separate settlement agreement, not seeking possession under the builder-buyer agreement, and since that settlement was signed in Delhi and the developer is located in Delhi, Section 20(c) of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) gave the Delhi High Court jurisdiction. The developer also claimed an oral understanding that the buyer would take the units instead if it could not raise the refund money. The Court rejected this because the written settlement contained no such term, and a written document excludes oral claims that contradict it. Applying the Supreme Court's test in Reliance Eminent Trading, it found the developer had no real prospect of defending the claim, called the defence "moonshine", and passed a decree for Rs. 4,07,81,000 with interest at 9% a year from 18 July 2023.
Lesson Learnt
A builder who signs a written settlement promising a refund cannot later avoid it by claiming an unwritten side arrangement. Where the defence is plainly weak, a commercial court can decide the claim quickly through summary judgment without a full trial.