Delhi Transport Corporation vs. Suresh Chand
Background
A DTC bus conductor stopped reporting for duty from October 1989. DTC declared him "deemed to have resigned" under a service regulation after he didn't respond to notices. The Labour Court ruled this illegal because DTC never actually considered leave applications he had submitted, ordering reinstatement with full back wages.
Decision Breakdown
The Court agreed DTC's own witness admitted the leave applications were never looked at: the "show cause" process was a hollow formality, not genuine consideration as natural justice requires. The regulation DTC relied on was itself later declared unconstitutional and withdrawn. Since Suresh Chand had reached retirement age and already received a large recovered sum, the Court modified relief from reinstatement to a lump-sum Rs. 2,00,000 compensation.
Lesson Learnt
An employer cannot treat an employee's explanation for absence as a mere formality: if explanations are submitted, they must actually be considered before harsh consequences like "deemed resignation" are imposed.