M/s Delhi Transco Ltd. vs. Nirmal Kumar
Background
Nirmal Kumar was given a job at Delhi Transco on compassionate grounds in 2002. In his attestation form (a background declaration filled in after joining) he said no criminal case was pending against him, but police verification found four. In a departmental enquiry he admitted the charge of giving false information, saying he did so out of fear of losing the job, and he was removed from service in 2005. In his later labour dispute, the Labour Court held as a first step that the enquiry was unfair because no evidence was led after his admission and he was not warned of its consequences.
Decision Breakdown
The High Court first held that it could hear the employer's challenge even though the Labour Court had decided only a preliminary issue, because the facts were on record, only the legal effect of the admission was in dispute, and the case had been pending since 2018. On the merits, it relied on Supreme Court rulings that when an employee clearly admits a charge in a departmental enquiry, asking the employer to lead further evidence is an empty formality. Nirmal Kumar admitted the charge more than once, including in front of his defence assistant (a co-worker who helps the employee in the enquiry), and repeated it in his own written representation. The Court found the Labour Court's reasons did not hold up, set aside its order, held the enquiry fair and proper, and sent the case back to decide the remaining issues, with the parties to appear on 1 December 2026. It made clear that questions about whether the punishment and his removal were justified were left for the Labour Court.
Lesson Learnt
An employee who clearly and repeatedly admits a charge in a departmental enquiry will generally find it hard to later argue that the enquiry was unfair because no evidence was taken. Anyone facing such an enquiry should understand that an admission, even with an explanation attached, can be treated as proof of the charge.