Mool Chand Khairati Ram Hospital vs. Indiver
Background
Indiver, made permanent as Assistant Housekeeper in 1995, had his post abolished in 1998 while a related labour dispute (where he was an active union representative) was pending, without following the required procedure. A tribunal ruled this void and ordered reinstatement. The hospital reinstated him in 2008 but terminated him again in 2026 over a 2025 absenteeism charge-sheet.
Decision Breakdown
The Court found no flaw in the tribunal's ruling that the 1998 abolition breached statutory protection for an active union representative during a pending dispute, and upheld that finding. But since Indiver had already been reinstated, received back-wages, and was separately terminated again on different grounds (which he remains free to challenge separately), reinstatement had been overtaken by events. The Court converted the surviving dispute into a lump-sum Rs. 3,00,000 compensation.
Lesson Learnt
Terminating an active union representative during a pending labour dispute without following the required procedure can be struck down even years later, but once reinstatement has happened and a fresh, separate termination occurs, courts typically settle the old dispute with a one-time payment.