Ankit Saraiya v. Pooja Saraiya
Background
The couple married in January 2013 and have a son born in 2017. In 2020 the wife filed a case under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, and a Kolkata magistrate ordered the husband to pay Rs. 1.5 lakh a month (Rs. 90,000 for the child and Rs. 60,000 for alternative accommodation). Disputes followed over whether the wife was in fact living in the matrimonial home at Hastings Park Road, Kolkata, and the Calcutta High Court held she could not claim alternative accommodation while occupying that home; the husband appealed to the Supreme Court, saying the marriage had irretrievably broken down.
Decision Breakdown
At the Supreme Court's suggestion, the parties negotiated and reached a full settlement: Rs. 30 crore as permanent alimony to the wife, Rs. 45 crore for the minor son to be held by the wife in trust, a home worth up to Rs. 5 crore bought from the trust funds in which the wife may live until she remarries or the son turns 25, handover of the Kolkata family home, and the father's visitation as per the parenting plan. All 14 listed civil, criminal and matrimonial cases between the parties and their families were to be closed. Using its special power under Article 142 of the Constitution to do "complete justice," the Court dissolved the marriage, made the settlement part of its order, and directed that any future disagreement over the parenting plan be first resolved in good faith with the child's welfare as the paramount concern, failing which either parent may approach the competent court.
Lesson Learnt
Even bitterly fought matrimonial disputes spread across many courts can be ended in one stroke through a negotiated settlement, which the Supreme Court can enforce and use to grant a divorce under Article 142. In any such settlement, the child's welfare remains the guiding consideration for custody and visitation.