Poornima Gupta v. Saurav Gupta
Background
This order does not finally decide the contempt petition. A separating couple settled their disputes through mediation, and the Supreme Court recorded the settlement in its order of 12 December 2025: both children (a daughter about 11 and a son about 6) would live with the mother, while the father could take them to his parental home in Dholpur, Rajasthan, twice a year for four days, and would pay Rs. 8,000 a month for their education. On 22 July 2026 the father picked up the son from his school in Delhi, supposedly under his visitation rights, and kept him in Rajasthan for nearly four months, enrolling him in a local school. The mother's police complaint went unanswered, so she filed a contempt petition in the Supreme Court; the father admitted keeping the child but said the boy wanted to stay with him.
Decision Breakdown
This is an interim order, not a final judgment; the case returns on 22 January 2027. After speaking with the child and the parents in chambers, the Court found the father to be in clear contempt of its order, and observed that the child's mind appeared to have been severely tutored against his mother and sister; it also noted that the father prima facie seemed to show signs of substance abuse. Even so, the Court considered an abrupt transfer of the child back to the mother unsafe, as it could leave a lasting psychological scar. It directed the Family Court at Dholpur to engage a child counsellor to hold sessions (initially twice a week) in an influence-free setting at the court premises, aimed at restoring the child's trust in his mother and sister; the father must bring the child, cannot interfere, and must pay the counsellor's fees, and the mother may seek permission to join. The child may stay in Dholpur until the counsellor's report, which is to be placed before the Court in a sealed cover on 22 January 2027 (earlier if the child is ready to return).
Lesson Learnt
Custody and visitation terms recorded in a court order are binding, and a parent who uses visiting rights to snatch and keep a child is in contempt of court. Even then, courts put the child's psychological well-being first and may use professional counselling to undo parental alienation rather than ordering a sudden handover.