Helena Anna Maria Lersch v. State of Goa
Background
This judgment decides only interim custody, not the final guardianship case. An unmarried couple (a German mother working in Singapore as a senior public-policy executive and an Indian father running a law firm in New Delhi) had a son in New Delhi in July 2022, who grew up mainly in Delhi and Goa. After the relationship broke down, the mother alleged that from February 2026 the father kept the child from her (including cutting off contact for about six weeks and moving between Kolkata, Bangalore and Mysore), so she filed a habeas corpus petition (a plea to produce a person allegedly being wrongly held) in the Bombay High Court at Goa; meanwhile the father started guardianship proceedings, now transferred to the Family Court at Patiala House, New Delhi. When the High Court adjourned her plea, she came to the Supreme Court seeking interim custody and permission to take the four-year-old to school in Singapore; mediation failed, and the Court had the family assessed by NIMHANS, Bengaluru.
Decision Breakdown
This is not a final judgment on custody: the final guardianship decision is left to the Family Court. The Supreme Court held it could decide interim custody in this habeas corpus proceeding under its "parens patriae" power (the court's duty to act as protector of a child's welfare), rejecting the father's objection that the matter belonged only to the Family Court. Applying the three-part test for interim relief, it found that the mother of a very young child born outside marriage has a better prima facie claim to custody, that the balance of convenience favoured her (forcing her to stay in India would mean giving up her job, while the father, a lawyer with resources, could more easily travel), and that the child faced real harm from the current lack of formal schooling, for which the mother had a concrete plan while the father had shown no admission documents. The NIMHANS report negated the father's allegations about the mother's mental health. Interim custody was granted to the mother to take the child to Singapore, but only after she obtains a "mirror order" (a matching order from a Singapore court so the arrangement is enforceable there) within three weeks and deposits Rs. 1 crore with the Supreme Court Registry; a detailed parenting plan gives the father daily video calls, visits and weekend custody in Singapore, and custody during school vacations of over 7 days in India, with six-monthly psychological checks to guard against the child being turned against the father, and the final guardianship decision left to the Family Court.
Lesson Learnt
In custody disputes the child's best interests come first, ahead of either parent's convenience or legal technicalities, and for a very young child of unmarried parents the mother generally has a stronger initial claim. When a child is allowed to move abroad during a pending case, courts can use safeguards like mirror orders, security deposits and guaranteed contact to protect the other parent's relationship with the child.