Kamal Gupta v. Nisha Gupta
Background
The couple married on 3 December 1997 and have two sons. A Family Court ordered the husband to pay his wife interim maintenance (temporary financial support while the case is pending) of Rs. 75,000 a month; the High Court dismissed his appeal and, on the wife's appeal, raised it to Rs. 1,50,000 a month. The husband runs a partnership firm making auto cables in Delhi with an annual turnover of Rs. 6.6 crore, has seven bank accounts, deposited Rs. 91 lakh in his account over two years, invested Rs. 16 lakh in mutual funds in a single transaction, and gifted a flat to his brother in 2018.
Decision Breakdown
After examining both sides' financial affidavits (mandatory disclosure of income and assets under the Court's ruling in Rajnesh v. Neha), the Supreme Court found the High Court's increase to Rs. 1,50,000 a month neither perverse nor unreasonable given the husband's business and investments, and dismissed his appeals. In the wife's contempt petitions, it noted that he had still not paid the arrears despite earlier Supreme Court orders (18 December 2025 and 15 January 2026) directing payment within four months. It gave him a further three months to clear all arrears at the High Court's rate, failing which the wife may file fresh contempt petitions.
Lesson Learnt
Maintenance is fixed on a spouse's real financial capacity (business turnover, bank deposits, investments and property transfers), not just on what they say they earn. Ignoring court orders to pay maintenance arrears can expose the defaulter to contempt proceedings.