Commissioner of Income Tax, International Taxation-1, New Delhi vs. Emerging India Focus Funds
Background
Emerging India Focus Funds is a Mauritius-resident investment fund registered with SEBI that invests in Indian equity-oriented mutual funds. For Assessment Year 2022-23, it earned capital gains (profit on sale of an investment) of about Rs. 593 crore from selling mutual fund units and claimed this was not taxable in India under the India-Mauritius Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement (DTAA), a treaty that decides which country can tax which income. The tax officer and the Dispute Resolution Panel treated the units like shares, since such funds mainly hold Indian shares, and taxed the gains in India. The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) disagreed, and the tax department appealed to the High Court.
Decision Breakdown
The question was whether gains from selling units of equity-oriented mutual funds fall under Article 13(3A) of the DTAA, which lets India tax gains from selling shares of an Indian company acquired on or after 1 April 2017. The Court held that a mutual fund unit holder is not a shareholder of any company: a unit is only an undivided interest in a fund set up as a trust, as defined in the SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 1996, and the unit holder has none of a shareholder's rights or liabilities. It noted that Indian tax law itself treats equity shares and units of equity-oriented funds as separate items, and relied on the Supreme Court's ruling in Apollo Tyres Ltd. v. CIT that units are not deemed shares. Rejecting the department's call for a "purposive" (intent-based) reading, it said treaty terms must be read strictly because the two countries deliberately divided taxing rights. The gains therefore fall under Article 13(4), taxable only in Mauritius, and the department's appeal was dismissed.
Lesson Learnt
For tax treaty purposes, the Court held that owning mutual fund units is not the same as owning company shares, even when the fund invests mostly in shares. Treaty wording is applied as written, and the tax department cannot stretch a clause beyond the words the two countries agreed.