Sterling and Wilson Pvt. Ltd. v. Union of India
Background
Sterling and Wilson sets up solar power generating (SPG) systems for customers on a turnkey basis. For the period 1 July 2017 to 31 December 2018 it paid GST at the concessional 5% rate that a government notification applied to "solar power generating systems." A rule introduced from 1 January 2019 split such contracts into 70% goods (taxed at 5%) and 30% services (taxed at 18%), and a 2021 government circular said taxpayers "can" use this 70:30 split for earlier periods too. GST officers in Thane used that circular to demand roughly Rs. 53.36 crore in central and state tax plus penalties for the earlier period, accusing the company of wilful suppression; the Bombay High Court refused to hear the company's challenge, saying it should first file a statutory appeal (which required a pre-deposit).
Decision Breakdown
The Supreme Court held that the High Court should not have brushed the writ petition aside, since the existence of an alternative appeal remedy is not a rigid bar when serious arguable points are raised; it then decided the matter itself. It held that the 70:30 rule applied only from 1 January 2019, and the 2021 circular merely gave taxpayers an option to use it for earlier years: it did not force it on anyone. Because the solar panels can be detached from their concrete foundations and used elsewhere, the systems are movable goods, so the contract was not a "works contract" (a contract to build immovable property); the Court endorsed the Andhra Pradesh High Court's consistent view on this point. As the new rule did not even exist at the time, there was no basis to allege fraud or suppression and invoke the longer limitation period under Section 74 of the CGST Act. The appeal was allowed and the tax demand orders of 17 and 24 January 2025 were set aside.
Lesson Learnt
A tax rule that comes into force on a particular date cannot be imposed on earlier transactions, and a government circular saying taxpayers "can" adopt a method is an option, not a compulsion. Equipment bolted to a foundation only to keep it stable, and removable for use elsewhere, is generally movable property, not part of the land.